{"generated":"2026-06-15","axes":[{"key":"scale","label":"Can't scale (by-product)"},{"key":"diversify","label":"Can't diversify (concentrated)"},{"key":"recycle","label":"Can't recycle out"},{"key":"demand","label":"Demand surging"},{"key":"thin","label":"No slack (thin market)"}],"n":32,"n_hardest":2,"hardest":["Gallium","Germanium"],"axis_totals":{"scale":7,"diversify":17,"recycle":21,"demand":3,"thin":4},"rows":[{"label":"gallium","title":"Gallium","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":true,"thin":true},"detail":{"scale":"100% by-product","diversify":"top producer 99%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~2.5\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"987 t world"},"count":5,"known":5,"companionality_pct":100,"world_tonnes":987},{"label":"germanium","title":"Germanium","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":true},"detail":{"scale":"100% by-product","diversify":"top producer 93%","recycle":"2% recycled","demand":"~2.0\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"150 t world"},"count":4,"known":5,"companionality_pct":100,"world_tonnes":150},{"label":"arsenic","title":"Arsenic","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"100% by-product","diversify":"top producer 51%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.2\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"63 kt world"},"count":3,"known":5,"companionality_pct":100,"world_tonnes":62768},{"label":"vanadium","title":"Vanadium","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"90% by-product","diversify":"top producer 68%","recycle":"2% recycled","demand":"~2.0\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"113 kt world"},"count":3,"known":5,"companionality_pct":90,"world_tonnes":112506},{"label":"graphite","title":"Graphite","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":true,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 76%","recycle":"3% recycled","demand":"~2.75\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"1.7 Mt world"},"count":3,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":1685817},{"label":"beryllium","title":"Beryllium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":true},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 59%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.4\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"10 kt world"},"count":3,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":9679},{"label":"hafnium","title":"Hafnium","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"100% by-product","diversify":"top producer 60%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.7\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"no tonnage data"},"count":2,"known":4,"companionality_pct":100,"world_tonnes":null},{"label":"helium","title":"Helium","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"100% by-product","diversify":"top producer 37%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.6\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"no tonnage data"},"count":2,"known":4,"companionality_pct":100,"world_tonnes":null},{"label":"cobalt","title":"Cobalt","flags":{"scale":true,"diversify":true,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"90% by-product","diversify":"top producer 74%","recycle":"22% recycled","demand":"~1.7\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"269 kt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":90,"world_tonnes":268755},{"label":"tantalum","title":"Tantalum","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":true},"detail":{"scale":"50% by-product","diversify":"top producer 41%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.7\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"3 kt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":50,"world_tonnes":2776},{"label":"magnets","title":"Rare earths / magnets","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"40% by-product","diversify":"top producer 68%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.79\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"398 kt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":40,"world_tonnes":398008},{"label":"fluorspar","title":"Fluorspar","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"5% by-product","diversify":"top producer 68%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"9.7 Mt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":5,"world_tonnes":9742717},{"label":"niobium","title":"Niobium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 92%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"123 kt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":123206},{"label":"boron","title":"Boron","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 45%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"5.2 Mt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":5238309},{"label":"lithium","title":"Lithium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":true,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 38%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~5.86\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"602 kt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":601914},{"label":"feldspar","title":"Feldspar","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 25%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.2\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"36.4 Mt world"},"count":2,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":36353265},{"label":"strontium","title":"Strontium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 75%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.4\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"no tonnage data"},"count":2,"known":4,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":null},{"label":"platinum","title":"Platinum","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"25% by-product","diversify":"top producer 70%","recycle":"14% recycled","demand":"~1.9\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"179 kt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":25,"world_tonnes":178929},{"label":"tungsten","title":"Tungsten","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"10% by-product","diversify":"top producer 78%","recycle":"42% recycled","demand":"~1.6\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"75 kt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":10,"world_tonnes":75416},{"label":"nickel","title":"Nickel","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"5% by-product","diversify":"top producer 62%","recycle":"16% recycled","demand":"~1.85\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"3.7 Mt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":5,"world_tonnes":3699741},{"label":"magnesium","title":"Magnesium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":true,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 66%","recycle":"13% recycled","demand":"~1.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"21.0 Mt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":21042652},{"label":"silicon","title":"Silicon","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 47%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~2.2\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"no tonnage data"},"count":1,"known":4,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":null},{"label":"manganese","title":"Manganese","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 39%","recycle":"9% recycled","demand":"~1.7\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"18.8 Mt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":18818965},{"label":"baryte","title":"Baryte","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 22%","recycle":"1% recycled","demand":"~1.1\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"9.4 Mt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":9377075},{"label":"phosphorus","title":"Phosphorus","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 44%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~1.4\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"77.3 Mt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":77279130},{"label":"cokingcoal","title":"Coking coal","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":true,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 49%","recycle":"0% recycled","demand":"~0.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"1.1 Bt world"},"count":1,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":1050336169},{"label":"antimony","title":"Antimony","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"60% by-product","diversify":"top producer 33%","recycle":"28% recycled","demand":"~1.8\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"141 kt world"},"count":0,"known":5,"companionality_pct":60,"world_tonnes":141231},{"label":"palladium","title":"Palladium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"50% by-product","diversify":"top producer 41%","recycle":"14% recycled","demand":"n/a","thin":"209 kt world"},"count":0,"known":4,"companionality_pct":50,"world_tonnes":208959},{"label":"titanium","title":"Titanium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"20% by-product","diversify":"top producer 36%","recycle":"19% recycled","demand":"~1.7\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"9.0 Mt world"},"count":0,"known":5,"companionality_pct":20,"world_tonnes":9005073},{"label":"copper","title":"Copper","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"5% by-product","diversify":"top producer 24%","recycle":"17% recycled","demand":"~1.38\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"22.9 Mt world"},"count":0,"known":5,"companionality_pct":5,"world_tonnes":22911145},{"label":"bauxite","title":"Bauxite / aluminium","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 34%","recycle":"32% recycled","demand":"~1.9\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"414.0 Mt world"},"count":0,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":414033986},{"label":"phosphate","title":"Phosphate rock","flags":{"scale":false,"diversify":false,"recycle":false,"demand":false,"thin":false},"detail":{"scale":"0% by-product","diversify":"top producer 44%","recycle":"17% recycled","demand":"~1.4\u00d7 by 2040","thin":"77.3 Mt world"},"count":0,"known":5,"companionality_pct":0,"world_tonnes":77279130}]}