{
 "weights": {
  "production": 0.3,
  "refining": 0.25,
  "trade": 0.25,
  "opacity": 0.2
 },
 "year": "2024",
 "materials": [
  {
   "label": "beryllium",
   "title": "Beryllium, unwrought",
   "score": 74,
   "gross": 74,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 58,
    "refining": 65,
    "trade": 79.9,
    "opacity": 100.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "lithium",
   "title": "Lithium carbonate",
   "score": 65,
   "gross": 65,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 48,
    "refining": 74,
    "trade": 58.9,
    "opacity": 84.4
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "niobium",
   "title": "Ferro-niobium",
   "score": 64,
   "gross": 64,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 90,
    "refining": 88,
    "trade": 59.7,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "magnesium",
   "title": "Magnesium, unwrought",
   "score": 60,
   "gross": 63,
   "recycling": 13,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 88,
    "refining": 94,
    "trade": 53.5,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "gallium",
   "title": "Gallium",
   "score": 58,
   "gross": 58,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 98,
    "refining": 98,
    "trade": 15.8,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": true
  },
  {
   "label": "strontium",
   "title": "Strontium carbonate",
   "score": 57,
   "gross": 57,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 38,
    "refining": 60,
    "trade": 40.8,
    "opacity": 100.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "phosphorus",
   "title": "Phosphorus",
   "score": 56,
   "gross": 56,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 41,
    "refining": 78,
    "trade": 34.3,
    "opacity": 76.2
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "magnets",
   "title": "Rare-earth permanent magnets",
   "score": 52,
   "gross": 52,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 69,
    "refining": 84,
    "trade": 42.4,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "cobalt",
   "title": "Cobalt oxides & hydroxides",
   "score": 52,
   "gross": 57,
   "recycling": 22,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 74,
    "refining": 82,
    "trade": 18.2,
    "opacity": 47.9
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "graphite",
   "title": "Natural graphite",
   "score": 51,
   "gross": 52,
   "recycling": 3,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 77,
    "refining": 94,
    "trade": 21.6,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "tungsten",
   "title": "Tungsten, unwrought",
   "score": 50,
   "gross": 60,
   "recycling": 42,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 81,
    "refining": 86,
    "trade": 56.4,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "fluorspar",
   "title": "Fluorspar, >97% CaF2",
   "score": 50,
   "gross": 50,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 65,
    "refining": 60,
    "trade": 25.3,
    "opacity": 45.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "germanium",
   "title": "Germanium",
   "score": 47,
   "gross": 48,
   "recycling": 2,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 68,
    "refining": 94,
    "trade": 15.8,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": true
  },
  {
   "label": "silicon",
   "title": "Silicon, < 99.99%",
   "score": 47,
   "gross": 47,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 73,
    "refining": 79,
    "trade": 20.2,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "vanadium",
   "title": "Ferro-vanadium",
   "score": 46,
   "gross": 46,
   "recycling": 2,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 68,
    "refining": 62,
    "trade": 12.7,
    "opacity": 35.1
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "manganese",
   "title": "Manganese ore",
   "score": 46,
   "gross": 47,
   "recycling": 9,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 36,
    "refining": 95,
    "trade": 33.2,
    "opacity": 22.7
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "bauxite",
   "title": "Aluminium ores / bauxite",
   "score": 45,
   "gross": 52,
   "recycling": 32,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 24,
    "refining": 60,
    "trade": 54.9,
    "opacity": 80.3
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "titanium",
   "title": "Titanium, unwrought",
   "score": 43,
   "gross": 47,
   "recycling": 19,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 67,
    "refining": 67,
    "trade": 18.6,
    "opacity": 27.1
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "boron",
   "title": "Natural borates",
   "score": 41,
   "gross": 42,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 47,
    "refining": 60,
    "trade": 37.7,
    "opacity": 15.4
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "platinum",
   "title": "Platinum, unwrought",
   "score": 39,
   "gross": 42,
   "recycling": 14,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 67,
    "refining": 70,
    "trade": 16.7,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "antimony",
   "title": "Antimony, unwrought",
   "score": 35,
   "gross": 40,
   "recycling": 28,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 48,
    "refining": 75,
    "trade": 17.1,
    "opacity": 10.7
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "hafnium",
   "title": "Hafnium, unwrought",
   "score": 33,
   "gross": 33,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 31,
    "refining": 49,
    "trade": 15.8,
    "opacity": 37.6
   },
   "shared": true
  },
  {
   "label": "tantalum",
   "title": "Tantalum, unwrought",
   "score": 33,
   "gross": 34,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 41,
    "refining": 40,
    "trade": 16.1,
    "opacity": 35.9
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "nickel",
   "title": "Nickel, unwrought",
   "score": 32,
   "gross": 35,
   "recycling": 16,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 50,
    "refining": 45,
    "trade": 9.6,
    "opacity": 29.8
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "arsenic",
   "title": "Arsenic",
   "score": 31,
   "gross": 31,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 45,
    "refining": 50,
    "trade": 18.3,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "phosphate",
   "title": "Phosphate rock",
   "score": 30,
   "gross": 33,
   "recycling": 17,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 41,
    "refining": 40,
    "trade": 15.4,
    "opacity": 32.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "feldspar",
   "title": "Feldspar",
   "score": 27,
   "gross": 27,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "low",
   "components": {
    "production": 23,
    "refining": 30,
    "trade": 22.5,
    "opacity": 33.6
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "palladium",
   "title": "Palladium, unwrought",
   "score": 25,
   "gross": 27,
   "recycling": 14,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 44,
    "refining": 40,
    "trade": 14.3,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "copper",
   "title": "Refined copper cathodes",
   "score": 24,
   "gross": 26,
   "recycling": 17,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 23,
    "refining": 47,
    "trade": 11.3,
    "opacity": 21.1
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "cokingcoal",
   "title": "Coking coal",
   "score": 22,
   "gross": 22,
   "recycling": 0,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 30,
    "refining": 20.7,
    "trade": 20.7,
    "opacity": 15.6
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "helium",
   "title": "Helium",
   "score": 21,
   "gross": 22,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "high",
   "components": {
    "production": 46,
    "refining": 15.4,
    "trade": 15.4,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  },
  {
   "label": "baryte",
   "title": "Baryte",
   "score": 15,
   "gross": 15,
   "recycling": 1,
   "substitutability": "medium",
   "components": {
    "production": 32,
    "refining": 11.1,
    "trade": 11.1,
    "opacity": 0.0
   },
   "shared": false
  }
 ]
}